Please do not leave this page until complete. This can take a few moments.
It's rare that the word “exciting” and tax law are joined in the same sentence, but excited is what everyone from attorneys to developers are about the new Opportunity Zone tax benefit.
“I think it's really exciting,” says Kris Eimicke, a tax law and economic development attorney at Pierce Atwood in Portland. “It has the potential for significant impact.”
Drew Anderson, real estate director at Murray Plumb & Murray in Portland, says there's more attention on the new law than he's seen on a tax rule in a long time. “It's a new toy, and people are pretty excited.”
Kevin Mattson, of Dirigo Capital Advisors, a partner on what may be the first Opportunity Zone project in the country, feels the same way.
“The impact this is going to have is really exciting,” he says.
The program is new, the rules aren't final, and developers and investors are very interested in the possibilities. As the front line of any commercial development, law firms that have a focus on real estate development are scrambling to stay on top of the program.
The Opportunity Zone tax benefit, which came out of the federal tax overhaul, is designed to encourage development in designated zones across the U.S. that are considered low-income or in need of development. Maine's 32 zones were announced in May. There are 8,761 zones across the U.S. and its territories.
Proposed rules were released by the U.S. Treasury Oct. 19 and may be finalized by the end of the year after a 60-day comment period.
The program allows capital gains to be put into a fund for a designated Opportunity Zone within six months of the gains being realized. Once that's done, they're not taxed until Dec. 31, 2026. The longer the property is held, the more the tax benefit. After five years, 10% of the property would be excluded from taxes; that rises to 15% after seven years. After 10 years, all of the gains are tax-free.
A special fund must be set up for a zone project, usually in the form of an LLC.
The money is expected to be used to redevelop a struggling property or business. Money rolled back into the fund can be reinvested into the same building or business, or others in the same zone.
The U.S. Treasury has estimated $100 billion may pour into the program.
Anderson was the legal advisor on what may be one of the first Opportunity Zone projects in the country, the redevelopment of 333 Water St., in Augusta.
“I guess that makes me an expert,” he says with a laugh.
The former Odd Fellows Hall is in the Opportunity Zone that extends from Augusta's western border to the Kennebec River, bounded by Western Avenue to the south and Bond Brook to the north — which includes all of the city's downtown and a huge part of its historic residential area.
When the project was brought to Anderson, “I tackled it without much choice,” he says. “Since then, I've been doing some research.”
He says he's not different from attorneys at other firms. “We're just starting to grapple with it. More and more clients are asking about it, and we're having to figure it out.”
“This building could've been an Opportunity Zone project,” Eimicke says as he sits in Pierce Atwood's fifth-floor conference room on Portland's waterfront.
When the zones were announced, some questioned the fact that part of Portland's active peninsula commercial district was included with places like huge swaths of Aroostook and Washington counties, Millinocket, downtown Augusta and other areas that seem more obviously distressed.
Sorting out the nuances of the new program is part of what attorneys advising investors and developers do.
“I wasn't surprised at all by the [Portland] designation,” says Eimicke. “There's a lot of development here, but there's potential for a lot more.”
It's not only about development property, but developing business, adds Rob Ravenelle, head of the federal income tax practice at Pierce Atwood.
“People don't necessarily understand how it works until you explain it,” says Ravenelle. But, he adds, “It's not overly complicated,” and that makes it appealing to investors.
Eimicke says he's already working with a couple of Opportunity Zone projects, and both attorneys are fielding frequent questions.
“Nobody wants to be left behind,” Eimicke says. “They want to understand how it helps them and their projects.”
Developer Mattson says one of the “great things” about the program is that it's a tax benefit, not a tax credit, like most other programs.
“No one's writing a check,” he says.
He predicts the program will have more economic impact than Community Development Block grants, the venerable federal Housing and Urban Development program that has been pumping money into low-income areas in need of development since 1974.
One of the intriguing things about the program, and what makes it different from government-funded and tax credit programs, Mattson says, is that it's for individual projects and fueled by capital investment. He says that over the past few years, huge capital gains have built up, and investors are looking for places to funnel the money.
Eimicke, of Pierce Atwood, says, “What separates this from those other programs is the scale. It's only limited by geography, it's not limited by amount of money.”
It's similar in many ways to the New Markets Tax Credit program, which gives tax incentives to developers investing in distressed areas, Ravenelle says. That makes it easy for those investing to understand it, but he, too, stresses the scale difference.
“Only 25% of New Markets [zones] are qualified Opportunity Zones,” he says.
Murray, Plumb & Murray's Anderson suggests clients wait until the final regulations come out before making decisions related to the program.
“It's up for comment and some things may change,” he says. “They have to put some meat to the bones.”
While property development requires a legal opinion, Anderson says, “I always encourage clients to have an accountant take a look.”
Eimicke and Ravenelle also say investor enthusiasm is tempered by some caveats. For instance, not all development, even in qualified Opportunity Zone, is a good fit.
“It has to make economic sense, even before the tax pieces come together,” says Ravenelle.
Anderson also says areas that already have some development spark are more likely to see more of it through the program. Short-term economics are as important as the long-term investment.
“You still have to fill it with tenants who pay rent,” he says. “If you're the first one in a blighted area, you buy the property and fix it up, you still have to consider what kind of tenants you're going to get.”
Developer Mattson says the program isn't the reason to do a development. “It's part of the basket of tools,” he says.
He says most developers combine many economic drivers, particularly historic and low-income tax credits, CDBGs, tax increment financing districts and the New Markets tax credit. But he says it's an important tool — the one piece that can be the tipping point.
Eimicke and Ravenelle say they're proceeding with clients on Opportunity Zone projects.
“I think we can rely on the proposed regulations,” says Ravanelle, adding any changes probably won't be substantial.
“It's not likely the rules are going to be less investor-friendly,” Eimicke adds.